Apple’s first smart display is finally on shelves, and the first long review has landed. The Verge’s Jennifer Pattison Tuohy spent an extended period with the HomeView and gave it a score of 7 out of 10. Her verdict is warm, but uneven.
The $299 device does the basics extremely well. It controls smart home gear quickly, works as a hands-free kitchen companion, and sounds good for its size. It is also the first Apple smart speaker to ship with Siri AI inside. The Verge calls that an improvement, even if the assistant stays slow at times.
The screen is the star of the show. Customisable faces look gorgeous, and the display doubles as a digital photo frame. Guided cooking is excellent, and the panel handles timers, recipes, and household routines without much fuss.
Then Apple tried to turn it into a family iPhone. The HomeView can surface your texts, calendar, and reminders when your phone sits at home on the same Wi-Fi network. That turns a shared kitchen device into a container for personal data, and the handoff between the two modes is clumsy. Authentication checks interrupt simple tasks, and the display keeps pushing people back to their handset.
The review includes a striking privacy example. Tuohy says she could easily read her 15-year-old daughter’s text messages from the display, and the reverse was true as well. Her daughter’s conclusion was blunt: “I’ll just use my iPhone.” Her tech-averse husband had the opposite reaction and immediately asked for one for his office.
Other complaints are smaller but real. The app and widget setup feels funky, Siri AI still lags on complex requests, and wall mounts cost a lot extra. None of that ruins the core product. It simply means the HomeView excels as a hub and stumbles as a phone surrogate.
Apple is betting that the living room becomes the next AI battleground. The company has already opened preorders for a wider Home collection of devices, and it has been testing daily usage caps on cloud Siri tools. Cheap assistants do not stay cheap once they handle real household traffic.
For buyers, the pitch is straightforward. If you want a fast, attractive smart home controller with solid Siri integration, the HomeView delivers. If you expect a screen that juggles everyone’s messages without friction, wait for software updates. The hardware feels ready. The family sharing model does not.
Source: The Verge — Apple’s HomeView review
The Netherlands, for internationals
One email a week: the week's news for internationals in the Netherlands, new practical guides and what changed in the cities. No spam, unsubscribe any time.










