AI News
  • Home
  • Guides
  • Choose country
    • Netherlands
    • United Kingdom
    • Germany
    • France
  • Editorial Policy
  • Contact
  • English
  • العربية
No Result
View All Result
AI News
  • Home
  • Guides
  • Choose country
    • Netherlands
    • United Kingdom
    • Germany
    • France
  • Editorial Policy
  • Contact
  • English
  • العربية
No Result
View All Result
AI News
No Result
View All Result

Judge Accused of Using AI to Rule Can’t Be Sued, Court Says

Ramo by Ramo
21 August 2026
in AI in Law
0
0
SHARES
12
VIEWS
Summarize with ChatGPTShare to Facebook

A Nevada litigant thought he had found the crack in judicial immunity. In a federal suit against family court judge Mari Parladé, a plaintiff named Phillips argued that she never really decided his case at all. An AI did, he claimed. And if a machine wrote the ruling, his logic went, no judicial act ever took place, so the centuries-old shield that protects judges from being sued should not apply.

Last week a federal court told him no, in terms broader than he probably expected. U.S. District Judge Gloria Navarro dismissed the case and wrote that judicial immunity would hold even if a judge relied “wholly on artificial intelligence” to issue a ruling. Producing a decision in a pending case sits squarely within a judge’s ordinary duties, Navarro found, and immunity attaches to the act itself, not to the quality of the reasoning behind it. The order began circulating through legal blogs on August 17 and has been rattling around the profession since.

The evidence was thin. The principle was not.

Phillips built his AI theory on remarkably little. Judge Parladé read her ruling from a prepared script. She stumbled over a word. At one point she said “appearance of any impartiality” where the phrase should have been “appearance of impropriety.” That was the case: a verbal slip and a script, the kind of thing any judge reading from notes might produce on an ordinary afternoon in court.

⚖
RECOMMENDED READ
Law and Artificial Intelligence
Bart Custers and Eduard Fosch-Villaronga
A rigorous overview of AI impact on legal practice, liability frameworks and regulation worldwide.
View on Amazon →affiliate link

Navarro never had to decide whether the allegation was true. Her order makes no finding that Parladé used AI, no finding that she delegated anything, and no ruling that judges may hand their judgment to software. The point was narrower and, for exactly that reason, more sweeping: even taking the claim at face value, immunity applies. Phillips also tried the one recognized escape hatch, arguing that total delegation to a machine placed the ruling outside the judge’s jurisdiction, a rare exception that can defeat immunity. Navarro rejected that too. Issuing orders in a pending case is precisely what judges have jurisdiction to do, however they arrive at them.

Lawyers get sanctioned. Judges are immune.

The asymmetry is hard to miss. Attorneys who let chatbots write their briefs have been fined and referred to bar regulators across the country, and courts show less patience with each new incident. State Farm’s lawyers were caught citing cases that never existed just this month. A lawyer who files hallucinated citations answers for it personally, sometimes in front of a very unhappy judge. A judge who allegedly signs an AI-drafted order cannot be sued at all.

There is a reason the doctrine works this way. Judicial immunity exists so that every losing party cannot relitigate a case by suing the judge who decided it, and the remedy for a bad ruling is supposed to be appeal, not damages. The doctrine has survived accusations of bias, corruption and plain incompetence over more than a century of American case law. It was always going to survive an accusation of ChatGPT.

Advertisement

The accountability question immunity does not answer

Immunity from lawsuits is not the same as permission. Judges remain subject to appellate review and to judicial conduct commissions, and the AI question has already reached both. In late 2025, two federal judges acknowledged that AI-assisted drafting in their chambers had produced orders containing errors, after congressional scrutiny pushed the details into the open. The federal judiciary has since issued interim guidance cautioning judges against delegating core decision-making to AI tools.

That is where this fight will actually play out. A litigant who believes a machine decided their custody dispute or sentencing has no damages claim, but they can appeal, and they can file a complaint with the body that disciplines judges. Neither route has yet produced a clear national standard on when, whether and how judges must disclose AI use in their chambers. Nothing requires a judge to tell the parties at all.

Navarro’s order settles only the narrowest question: suing the judge is not an option. Everything else, from disclosure rules to whether litigants deserve to know when software helped write their fate, remains open. Expect the conduct commissions and the appellate courts, not damages suits, to answer it first.

For more coverage of AI and the law, visit Mylistingo.

The Netherlands, for internationals

One email a week: the week's news for internationals in the Netherlands, new practical guides and what changed in the cities. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

SummarizeShare
Ramo

Ramo

Ramo is the editor of Mylistingo, which publishes daily local news and practical guides for internationals living in the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, Germany, France and Spain, in English, Arabic and local languages. Every article links to the sources it is based on.

Related Stories

Pennsylvania Now Requires Labels on AI-Generated Ads

by Ramo
26 October 2026
0

Governor Josh Shapiro signed the AI Deceptive Advertising Act, requiring disclosures on ads generated or significantly modified by artificial intelligence.

Gavel and law books on a desk

California Passes SB 574: New AI Rules for Lawyers

by Ramo
3 September 2026
0

California's SB 574 would make lawyers verify AI output, disclose AI use in filings and protect client data. It now sits on Newsom's desk.

Parliamentary chamber in session

EU Labels ChatGPT a Search Engine Under the DSA

by Ramo
2 September 2026
0

The European Commission has designated ChatGPT a Very Large Online Search Engine, a first for an AI chatbot. OpenAI has four months to comply.

Anthropic gets its first court win over the Pentagon’s supply-chain risk label

Anthropic Wins First Round Against Pentagon Risk Label

by Ramo
28 August 2026
0

A court ruled that the Trump administration illegally branded Anthropic a supply-chain risk, handing the AI company its first courtroom win.

Next Post

AI's Gas Turbine Habit Could Lift US Power Emissions 20%

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Netherlands, for internationals

One email a week: the week's news for internationals in the Netherlands, new practical guides and what changed in the cities. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

SponsoredAdvertise
Free European Bank Account
Open a 100% mobile bank account in minutes
Free virtual Mastercard, zero foreign transaction fees, and instant European IBAN setup with no paperwork.
Get Started Free
SponsoredAdvertise
Second-hand marketplace
Sell the clothes you no longer wear, or buy pre-loved for less
Selling on Vinted is free, with no seller fees. Join with this invite link.
Join Vinted
PartnerAdvertise
For newcomers in the Netherlands
Your experience, a ready CV in Dutch
Tell us your experience in your own words. Get a CV and cover letter in Dutch, English, French or German, plus 10 job leads. 19 euro, once.
Start your order
SponsoredAdvertise
Web hosting
Build your website on Hostinger with 20% off your first purchase
Web hosting, VPS servers and an AI website builder. The 20% discount applies through this link.
Get 20% off
Mylistingo
For businesses
Advertise on Mylistingo
Reach internationals living in or moving to Europe. Send your ad text and image or video in two minutes.
Send your ad

Popular Story

  • Best Coffee Shops in The Hague 2026 — 10 Local Favorites

    Best Coffee Shops in The Hague 2026: 10 Local Favorites

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • how ai agents could take over online shopping tasks by 2026

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Enterprises hedge AI model strategy after Claude fable 5 blackout

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Gemini 2.5 Pro sets a new standard for ai reasoning

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Robotaxis Arrive in Rotterdam: Netherlands Launches Europe’s Largest Autonomous Ride-Hailing Fleet

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
logo ainews

Mylistingo: daily news and practical guides for internationals in the Netherlands, in English.

Recent Posts

  • Spain election: where the parties stand on housing and immigration
  • Toulouse cost of living march pushed back, incidents near Capitole
  • Frankfurt Christmas market: police station, cameras and knife ban

Partner

SponsoredAdvertise
Free European Bank Account
Open a 100% mobile bank account in minutes
Free virtual Mastercard, zero foreign transaction fees, and instant European IBAN setup with no paperwork.
Get Started Free

Categories

  • AI & Tech
  • AI & Tech in the Netherlands
  • AI in Business
  • AI in Climate
  • AI in Education
  • AI in Finance
  • AI in Health
  • AI in Law
  • AI in Sport
  • Amsterdam
  • Economy & Finance
  • Future Tech
  • Machine Learning
  • Moving to the Netherlands
  • Netherlands News
  • Politics & Geopolitics
  • Robotics
  • Rotterdam
  • Social Topics
  • Sport
  • Startups
  • The Hague
  • Tools & Apps
  • Uncategorized
  • Utrecht
  • Weekend Reads

The Hague, for internationals

One email a week: what changed for expats, what's on, one guide worth reading.

  • Home
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Latest News
  • Guides
  • Contact Us
  • Data Deletion Instructions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Editorial Policy

Published by AI Content Empire (KvK 42069591). Articles are AI-assisted, see our Editorial Policy.

  • English
  • العربية
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Guides
  • Choose country
    • Netherlands
    • United Kingdom
    • Germany
    • France
  • Editorial Policy
  • Contact

Published by AI Content Empire (KvK 42069591). Articles are AI-assisted, see our Editorial Policy.