AI News
  • Home
  • Guides
  • Choose country
    • Netherlands
    • United Kingdom
    • Germany
    • France
  • Editorial Policy
  • Contact
  • English
  • العربية
No Result
View All Result
AI News
  • Home
  • Guides
  • Choose country
    • Netherlands
    • United Kingdom
    • Germany
    • France
  • Editorial Policy
  • Contact
  • English
  • العربية
No Result
View All Result
AI News
No Result
View All Result

State Farm’s Lawyers Cited Cases That Never Existed

Ramo by Ramo
19 August 2026
in AI in Law
0
A wooden judge gavel resting on a dark surface
0
SHARES
11
VIEWS
Summarize with ChatGPTShare to Facebook

The cases were not weak. They were not there. Lawyers defending State Farm in a Los Angeles fire-damage lawsuit filed pretrial motions containing citations to decisions that do not exist, quotes nobody ever wrote, and holdings no court ever issued. The plaintiff’s team found them while preparing for trial, and the defence firm has now admitted the errors came from artificial intelligence software marketed to lawyers.

The underlying dispute is ordinary. Fa’alagilagi Meni-Siliga sued in July 2024 over fire damage to her home, naming a contractor, the contractor’s insurer, a public adjuster and State Farm, her homeowners insurance company, as defendants. The AI problem surfaced two years later, inside the motions that were supposed to shape what a jury would eventually hear.

What the plaintiff’s team found

Eric Khodadian, representing Meni-Siliga, set out the discovery in a court filing: the defence motions relied on cases, quotes and holdings that could not be located anywhere because none of them were real. Pulling and reading cited authority is basic litigation hygiene, and it is the step that has caught nearly every one of these incidents since the first ones surfaced in 2023.

⚖
RECOMMENDED READ
Law and Artificial Intelligence
Bart Custers and Eduard Fosch-Villaronga
A rigorous overview of AI impact on legal practice, liability frameworks and regulation worldwide.
View on Amazon →affiliate link

Kenneth Katel of Musick, Peeler and Garrett apologised to the court and to the plaintiff. By his account, a co-counsel used AI to help prepare some of the filings and he did not know it had been used. He did not hide behind that. “As lead trial counsel I accept full responsibility for our filings,” he wrote.

The supervision gap

What makes this one notable is not the hallucination. Fabricated citations have turned up in filings repeatedly since 2023, and judges have accumulated a small body of sanctions decisions in response. What stands out is where it happened: a defence firm acting for one of the largest insurers in the United States, on a case heading to trial, using software built specifically for legal research.

Purpose-built legal tools were supposed to close this failure mode. Retrieval-based research products ground their answers in actual case databases rather than a model’s memory, which is precisely the safeguard general-purpose chatbots lack. That architecture lowers the error rate. It does not remove the need for a human to open the case and read it, and this incident suggests verification is the step that keeps getting skipped when deadlines compress.

Advertisement

A mechanical fix has been available the whole time. Citators such as Shepard’s and KeyCite have let lawyers confirm that a case exists and remains good law for decades, and running a brief through one takes minutes. What generative drafting changed is the volume of citations arriving without a human having read the underlying opinion, which turns a routine check into the only thing standing between a draft and a sanctionable filing.

Pressure from the client side

The pressure driving that shortcut is measurable. Thomson Reuters found that 41 percent of law firms and 47 percent of corporate legal departments now report their legal teams using generative AI, up from 28 percent and 23 percent a year earlier. Thirty-eight percent of law firm professionals said they feel significant or some financial pressure to move faster on AI. And 32 percent of in-house legal professionals said they are already reconsidering relationships with firms that cannot show clear AI-enabled value within twelve months.

Read those three numbers together and the shape of the problem is hard to miss. Clients are demanding AI-driven efficiency, firms are adopting quickly to keep the work, and the verification burden that adoption creates lands on the same associates who were already short of hours.

Regulators are working to a different clock. In Europe, the EU AI Act’s high-risk obligations took effect on 2 August 2026, bringing mandatory logging, documentation and human oversight requirements to a defined set of systems, with fines reaching €15 million or 3 percent of global annual turnover. American courts have no equivalent framework. They have judges, standing orders on AI disclosure, and their own sanctions powers.

Judges have started closing the gap themselves. Standing orders requiring lawyers to disclose AI use in filings, or to certify that every citation has been verified by a human, have spread across US federal and state courts since 2023 without any central rule change. The result is a patchwork: the obligation on a lawyer now depends heavily on which courtroom the case lands in.

Sanctions in this matter have not been decided. The more interesting question is what happens to firm-level policy across insurance defence practices, where high volume and thin margins make AI-assisted drafting genuinely attractive. A rule requiring associates to verify every citation is easy to write. Enforcing it, when the entire appeal of the tool was saving the hour that verification takes, is the part nobody has solved.

For more coverage of AI and the legal profession, visit Mylistingo.

The Netherlands, for internationals

One email a week: the week's news for internationals in the Netherlands, new practical guides and what changed in the cities. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

SummarizeShare
Ramo

Ramo

Ramo is the editor of Mylistingo, which publishes daily local news and practical guides for internationals living in the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, Germany, France and Spain, in English, Arabic and local languages. Every article links to the sources it is based on.

Related Stories

Pennsylvania Now Requires Labels on AI-Generated Ads

by Ramo
26 October 2026
0

Governor Josh Shapiro signed the AI Deceptive Advertising Act, requiring disclosures on ads generated or significantly modified by artificial intelligence.

Gavel and law books on a desk

California Passes SB 574: New AI Rules for Lawyers

by Ramo
3 September 2026
0

California's SB 574 would make lawyers verify AI output, disclose AI use in filings and protect client data. It now sits on Newsom's desk.

Parliamentary chamber in session

EU Labels ChatGPT a Search Engine Under the DSA

by Ramo
2 September 2026
0

The European Commission has designated ChatGPT a Very Large Online Search Engine, a first for an AI chatbot. OpenAI has four months to comply.

Anthropic gets its first court win over the Pentagon’s supply-chain risk label

Anthropic Wins First Round Against Pentagon Risk Label

by Ramo
28 August 2026
0

A court ruled that the Trump administration illegally branded Anthropic a supply-chain risk, handing the AI company its first courtroom win.

Next Post
Relativity Networks raises $22 million to bring a faster kind of fiber to data centers

Relativity Networks Bets $22M on Hollow-Core Fiber

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Netherlands, for internationals

One email a week: the week's news for internationals in the Netherlands, new practical guides and what changed in the cities. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

SponsoredAdvertise
Free European Bank Account
Open a 100% mobile bank account in minutes
Free virtual Mastercard, zero foreign transaction fees, and instant European IBAN setup with no paperwork.
Get Started Free
SponsoredAdvertise
Second-hand marketplace
Sell the clothes you no longer wear, or buy pre-loved for less
Selling on Vinted is free, with no seller fees. Join with this invite link.
Join Vinted
PartnerAdvertise
For newcomers in the Netherlands
Your experience, a ready CV in Dutch
Tell us your experience in your own words. Get a CV and cover letter in Dutch, English, French or German, plus 10 job leads. 19 euro, once.
Start your order
SponsoredAdvertise
Web hosting
Build your website on Hostinger with 20% off your first purchase
Web hosting, VPS servers and an AI website builder. The 20% discount applies through this link.
Get 20% off
Mylistingo
For businesses
Advertise on Mylistingo
Reach internationals living in or moving to Europe. Send your ad text and image or video in two minutes.
Send your ad

Popular Story

  • Best Coffee Shops in The Hague 2026 — 10 Local Favorites

    Best Coffee Shops in The Hague 2026: 10 Local Favorites

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • how ai agents could take over online shopping tasks by 2026

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Enterprises hedge AI model strategy after Claude fable 5 blackout

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Gemini 2.5 Pro sets a new standard for ai reasoning

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Robotaxis Arrive in Rotterdam: Netherlands Launches Europe’s Largest Autonomous Ride-Hailing Fleet

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
logo ainews

Mylistingo: daily news and practical guides for internationals in the Netherlands, in English.

Recent Posts

  • Spain election: where the parties stand on housing and immigration
  • Toulouse cost of living march pushed back, incidents near Capitole
  • Frankfurt Christmas market: police station, cameras and knife ban

Partner

SponsoredAdvertise
Free European Bank Account
Open a 100% mobile bank account in minutes
Free virtual Mastercard, zero foreign transaction fees, and instant European IBAN setup with no paperwork.
Get Started Free

Categories

  • AI & Tech
  • AI & Tech in the Netherlands
  • AI in Business
  • AI in Climate
  • AI in Education
  • AI in Finance
  • AI in Health
  • AI in Law
  • AI in Sport
  • Amsterdam
  • Economy & Finance
  • Future Tech
  • Machine Learning
  • Moving to the Netherlands
  • Netherlands News
  • Politics & Geopolitics
  • Robotics
  • Rotterdam
  • Social Topics
  • Sport
  • Startups
  • The Hague
  • Tools & Apps
  • Uncategorized
  • Utrecht
  • Weekend Reads

The Hague, for internationals

One email a week: what changed for expats, what's on, one guide worth reading.

  • Home
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Latest News
  • Guides
  • Contact Us
  • Data Deletion Instructions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Editorial Policy

Published by AI Content Empire (KvK 42069591). Articles are AI-assisted, see our Editorial Policy.

  • English
  • العربية
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Guides
  • Choose country
    • Netherlands
    • United Kingdom
    • Germany
    • France
  • Editorial Policy
  • Contact

Published by AI Content Empire (KvK 42069591). Articles are AI-assisted, see our Editorial Policy.