Three of America’s largest school districts are now openly considering life without Google Search. New York, Los Angeles and Chicago are exploring alternatives after Google tied classroom search access to its Gemini AI features. The New York Times reported the shift on Wednesday.
Starting next year, schools will lose the ability to disable Gemini-powered features on their own. Turning off the company’s AI also switches off Search completely. Chris Phillips, Google’s vice president of education, defended the coupling in plain terms. “Search and AI are deeply integrated,” he told the Times, adding that schools rejecting AI “will not have access to Search.”
Elected officials responded with unusually blunt language. New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Senator Bernie Sanders both described the company’s position as “extortion.” Mamdani had recently announced a policy barring K-8 students from using AI in classrooms.
New York City schools chancellor Kamar H. Samuels signaled that the district is ready to walk. “If Google doesn’t reconsider their position, we will explore other search options,” he said in a statement. Chicago public schools delivered a similar warning to the company. The district said it will look elsewhere if Google cannot supply Search without AI.
Google pushed back with a statement to The Verge. Spokesperson Laura Breen said the company is piloting Guided Learning in Search this month. That feature walks students through problems step by step instead of handing over quick answers. Breen also promised a policy change next year. The Gemini app, Gemini Notebook and Search will be off by default until schools choose to enable them.
The standoff reflects wider unease about AI in classrooms. Educators worry about shrinking critical thinking skills, and some studies link AI use to weaker test performance. Child development experts have raised separate concerns about young students forming relationships with chatbots.
Leaving Google is easier said than done, though. American schools lean heavily on Google Classroom, Chromebooks and linked services every day. Ripping out that infrastructure would be a multi-year project for any large district. Google knows this, and its default-off promise is a concession that costs little in practice.
For now the districts are talking, not migrating. Google’s Gemini 4 rollout keeps expanding, and its free Gemini agent is now reaching ordinary users. Parents and teachers will decide whether this pressure campaign changes anything.
Source: The Verge — The nation’s largest school districts consider ditching Google Search
The Netherlands, for internationals
One email a week: the week's news for internationals in the Netherlands, new practical guides and what changed in the cities. No spam, unsubscribe any time.










